In the battle between CustomCat vs Printify, which provider will deliver the best print-on-demand service for your business? 🤔
Let’s start from the beginning: for e-commerce businesses exploring print-on-demand, choosing between providers like CustomCat and Printify is essential to delivering quality products and a smooth customer experience. In the following comparison of CustomCat’s and Printify’s unique features, benefits, and potential drawbacks you will find a complete guide to decide which one suits your online store.
As an overview, CustomCat and Printify offer print-on-demand services with integrations for major e-commerce platforms. They allow you to create custom products, including apparel, home decor, and accessories, without managing inventory or handling shipping logistics. Each has unique offerings and differences in product selection, pricing, quality control, and more.
🔵Product selection and quality
CustomCat
CustomCat’s product catalog includes over 500 items, from apparel to home and lifestyle goods. It is well-known for its emphasis on quality and for its durable printing processes like direct-to-garment (DTG) and dye sublimation, which are designed for long-lasting prints.
Printify
Printify collaborates with numerous printing partners, giving it an extensive selection of over 850 products. This variety means Printify users can access a diverse range of items beyond traditional apparel, including eco-friendly products. However, it is important to note that the quality can vary depending on the selected print partner, as each one has different standards.
🔵Pricing and profit margins
CustomCat
CustomCat offers three plans: a free plan, a subscription plan (CustomCat Pro) for $30/month, which reduces product costs and can help increase profit margins, and an enterprise plan that offers access to volume discounts. Additionally, CustomCat’s base prices tend to be lower, making it a good choice for businesses focused on maximizing profits.
Printify
Printify also has a free plan and a Premium plan for $29/month, which reduces base prices on products by up to 20%. Additionally, an enterprise plan is available for retailers with significant daily sales, but it offers custom pricing. With more partners and varied prices, Printify offers flexibility, especially for budget-conscious sellers, but it may require more research to find the best value.
🔵Integrations and ease of use
CustomCat
CustomCat integrates smoothly with popular platforms like Shopify, WooCommerce, and Etsy. While its interface is simple, it may feel less intuitive than Printify for beginners, though users generally appreciate its reliability once accustomed to it.
Printify
Printify’s interface is beginner-friendly and offers easy integration with many e-commerce platforms, among which we can find Shopify, Etsy, Amazon, TikTok, and eBay. Its platform provides seamless management of orders and mockups, with the advantage of an intuitive dashboard that is easy to navigate.
Both print-on-demand providers can be linked to product personalization tools like Customily, to allow your customers to personalize their designs directly on your online store and see their designs in real-time. The integration is done by using an API key to guarantee smooth operations among the platforms. Once your customer finishes the design and places the order, your print-on-demand provider receives a print file and can continue with the production and fulfillment of the purchase.
🔵Shipping and fulfillment
CustomCat
CustomCat’s fulfillment is centralized, which often results in reliable and consistent shipping times. They are known for fast production times, often within two or three days, though shipping speed may vary depending on location.
Printify
Printify’s decentralized approach, using multiple partners worldwide, offers flexible shipping options but may lead to variability in shipping speeds. However, this model also supports faster international fulfillment.
🔵Customer support and reliability
CustomCat
CustomCat has a reputation for quick customer support and detailed order tracking. Their emphasis on reliability means fewer issues with order accuracy, though some users mention limited options for extensive support hours.
Printify
Printify provides email and live chat support, as well as a comprehensive help center. With its network model, order tracking and support inquiries can be complicated if issues arise with a particular print partner.
Benefits and drawbacks
✅ CustomCat benefits
Consistent product quality: Due to in-house production, quality tends to be reliable.
Affordable pricing for high margins: With CustomCat Pro, users can access reduced prices, which can improve profit margins.
Quick turnaround: Faster production times offer quicker delivery to customers.
❌ CustomCat drawbacks
Limited product range: Fewer options compared to Printify.
Learning curve: Interface might take time to master for beginners.
✅ Printify benefits
Extensive product variety: It offers a broad range of unique items and eco-friendly options.
Flexible pricing plans: Its three available plans are accessible to sellers with different budgets.
User-friendly interface: It's really easy to use, especially for new print-on-demand sellers.
❌ Printify drawbacks
Inconsistent quality: The variations between print partners can impact quality control.
Complex order management: The fact that it works with different partners can make tracking and support more complex.
Both CustomCat and Printify have unique advantages that cater to different types of e-commerce sellers. Choosing between CustomCat and Printify ultimately depends on your business needs and priorities.
If you value consistency in quality, faster turnaround times, and competitive pricing, CustomCat could be a strong choice with its centralized approach. Meanwhile, Printify offers a wider range of products and flexible shipping options through its global network, making it ideal for those looking to offer more variety and reach international customers.
Consider your brand's goals, product needs, and budget to decide which platform will best support your print-on-demand success.
Happy customizing! 💫
ABOUT THE PUBLISHER
Customily Product Personalizer is the best solution to sell personalized products, both in the e-commerce and the print-on-demand market. With the widest range of personalization tools, free clipart designs, realistic live previews that increase conversions, and printing files that help you automate your printing business; Customily is the ally you need to boost your profit margins in a high-competitive market.
Visit our website to learn more about us.
Or try it for FREE on Shopify.
Comments